Dear Kyle —
I love you. More than words I do. There’s something about the way we talk and interact… I can tell you love me too.
At Union Fair this year, there was just something in they way you responded to a simple question I had asked you. “Do you think Alex is a good boyfriend?” I hadn’t expected a real answer. I had expected waffling. A run-around on the truth that was staring me in the face. I got what I hadn’t expected. “I would take you out to nice places.”
It broke my heart to hear that. Because, in that moment, I realized all this time you’ve cared about me and I had never noticed that. You knew exactly the way I was wishing I could be treated. You watched me slowly fall apart in my relationship with Taylor. You watched me be deceived in my relationship with David. You watched me flirt shamelessly with Benjamin. And then you watched me be disappointed in my relationship with Alex. You had seen all the ways these other guys had gone wrong.
You make me blush. Which is odd considering how much more experienced I am than you. I become bashful and feel the heat rise in my cheeks. It’s like I get a chance to start over. I don’t have to be the girl who feels like she’s been aged due to romantic relationships gone astray. I don’t have to be the girl that brags about her flexibility from when she was in gymnastics ten years ago. I can be the blushing virgin that’s nervous about hand-holding. A girl I haven’t been for three years.
It hurts. It really does. In my mind, I’ve idealized you. I’ve put you on a pedestal and that’s the reason I don’t want to get involved with you. I think that you are too good for me. I don’t think that I deserve it.
I’m afraid.
I’m afraid that you’ll come to resent me. I’m afraid what other people will think of our age difference. I’m afraid of ruining our friendship. That’s all bullshit, though. Those things shouldn’t matter. Really, I’m afraid of getting hurt.
How selfish is that?
— Yours, Rachel